SHIMANO FISHING REEL REVIEW – COMPARISON TEST
In this article, we’re diving into the top Shimano reels currently available on the market. At Tackle Cast, we prioritise providing high-quality information to anglers, equipping them with the best insights to make informed decisions when considering a reel purchase.
Within this article, we’ll comprehensively cover the specifications of each reel, outlining their pros and cons, as well as detailing what each reel is best suited for. Additionally, I’ll share my final thoughts to assist you in making a well-informed decision.
Why Trust My Shimano Reel Review?
My name is Daniel O’Neill, an avid angler from the UK with over fourteen years of fishing experience. I’ve had diverse encounters, from landing the mighty beluga sturgeon in Poland to targeting double-figure pike in the renowned Lough Erne.
Throughout the years, I’ve extensively tested various Shimano reels, pushing them to their limits. As a result, I can confidently provide fair and accurate reviews of their recent models.
Having had the privilege of testing a wide range of reels and handling some of the finest gear available, I continually seek the best all-around reel.
In terms of value for the price, quality, and robustness, Shimano stands out as having some of the best on the market.
Best Shimano reels at a glance
Shimano 24 Twin Power FE – Best Premium Reel
Shimano Sedona C4000XG FI – Best Mid-Price Range
Shimano Vanford 2500HGF – Best For Jigging
Shimano FX – Best Budget Reel
Shimano Catana – Best for feeder fishing
Shimano Baitrunner ST RB – Great for carp fishing
Shimao Baitrunner DL RB – Best tension sensitivity
Shimano 24 Twin Power FE – Best Premium Reel
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
Twinpower has established itself over three decades, showcasing its reliability, and Shimano’s latest model upholds this tradition. If you’re in search of a reel that’s not only lightweight but also impressively powerful, look no further than the brand-new Shimano 24 Twin Power FE.
This reel is adept at handling trophy fish and is best suited for using soft baits, float setups, or even crankbaits. It’s an all-around fantastic reel that can prove advantageous in almost any UK fishing scenario.
Whether you’re lure fishing for hefty pike or preparing to hook another competition-winning mirror carp, you can trust that this reel will withstand the test.
Pros
- The reel’s anti-twist fin helps to prevent slackline, crucial for ensuring your hook doesn’t slip.
- Advanced Long Stoke AR-C Spool, proven to increase casting distance.
- High and extra high gear options are available for increased retrieval speed.
Cons
- Relatively expensive compared to some of the other options on this list.
- Reel Size: 2000 – 500
- Gear Ratio: 5.1
- Line Capacity: 8-140, 10-120
- Max Drag: 20lbs
My Thoughts
I believe the Shimano 24 Twin Power FE is an outstanding piece of equipment, some anglers may be deterred from the plastic body, however, the CI4 material Shimano uses is vastly different from the cheaper zion plastic commonly found on budget Daiwa reels, due to being carbon fiber-reinforced.
The reel has a great selection of technologies like Infinity Drive and InfinityXcross helping to reduce angler fatigue when playing larger fish.
Shimano Sedona C4000XG FI – Best Mid-Price Range
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
This reel excels in general spinning, boasting a larger spool that facilitates long-distance casting. It’s particularly effective for targeting pike, perch, roach, and rudd. Crafted with an aluminium handle and spool, coupled with a blend of graphite and metal for the rest of its construction, it offers both durability and lightweight performance, making it ideal for prolonged periods of use on the water.
Pros
- A Compact G-Free Body.
- Varispeed II for altering the speed of the oscillation cam which helps to provide a smooth and balanced line lay.
- Super Stopper II front drag helps to remove any fallback of the reel handle when setting tips.
Cons
- The line lay on the Sedona isn’t great in comparison to other Shimano products.
- Reel Size: 4000
- Gear Ratio: 6.2:1
- Line Capacity: 10lb – 200yd
- Max Drag: 24.2lbs
My Thoughts
The Hagane gear system within the reel is renowned for its robustness. It undergoes a specialized forging process, guaranteeing a durable product that lasts over time.
This feature is typically associated with higher-end gear, making it a significant advantage for a mid-priced reel. Additionally, this reel is an excellent choice for those in need of a lightweight spinning reel.
While it may not be suitable for targeting large fish, it is well-suited for smaller to mid-sized catches.
Shimano Vanford 2500HGF – Best For Jigging
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
The Shimano Vanford is an outstanding reel tailored for light spinning or jigging activities, excelling in canals, small rivers, and lakes. It proves versatile across various species found in the UK’s waterways.
With its HAGANE Gear, MicroModule II, X-SHIP, and Silent Drive technologies working in harmony, the reel maintains ample power to handle larger catches effectively, ensuring a successful retrieval.
Pros
- The reel’s construction prioritizes lightweight design, perfect for finesse techniques like jigging or lure fishing.
- Its MGL rotor enhances sensitivity to a superb level.
- Crafted from Ci4+ composite material, it achieves an exceptional balance of lightweight feel and robust durability.
Cons
- It is expensive for a jigging/light lure fishing reel.
- Reel Size: 2500
- Gear Ratio: 6
- Line Capacity: 5-110, 6-95, 8-70
- Max Drag: 9lb
My Thoughts
This reel is highly praised for its sensitivity, enabling anglers to detect even the most subtle of bites. This feature proves invaluable when jigging for species such as brown trout and perch, where takes may not always be easily noticeable.
Its lightweight construction makes it an excellent choice for pairing with a travel rod, and its portability makes it convenient to carry in the car for impromptu fishing sessions whenever you find a moment of peace from work.
Shimano FX – Best Budget Reel
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
This reel is ideal for beginner anglers venturing into the world of fishing. It boasts durability and is manufactured by the world’s leading reel company, which has accumulated over a century of experience.
This heritage instills trust that your investment in the reel is worthwhile, especially if you’re just starting. It serves as an excellent entry point for those unsure if angling will become a primary hobby or for those not yet ready to make a substantial investment. Furthermore, it excels in targeting a variety of coarse species and is well-suited for river trout fishing.
Pros
- Cheap and great for beginners.
- It has a relatively strong XT-7 Body.
- AR-C long casting spool design made from aluminium not plastic.
Cons
- Most of its components are plastic.
- Limited ball bearings.
- Reel Size: 1000 – 4000
- Gear Ratio: 5.0:1 – 5.2:1
- Line Capacity: 0.18-170
- Max Drag: 8.8lbs – 18.7lbs
My Thoughts
The Shimano FX is widely regarded as a solid choice for beginners, and many experienced anglers may also recall starting or using one at some point in their angling journey. However, for more advanced anglers, I would recommend considering other options.
The reel’s drawback lies in its minimal two-ball bearings, which support the gears and spool during the fight with the fish. This lack of ball bearings can be a disadvantage under load, affecting performance.
However, if you’re primarily targeting beginner sport fish, this may not be a major concern. Additionally, there are reports of individuals successfully landing larger carp weighing up to 15 pounds on this reel.
Shimano Catana – Best For Feeder Fishing
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
Shimano’s reel boasts 3 stainless steel ball bearings alongside a roller bearing, contributing to its better-than-average performance. Positioned at the more affordable end of today’s market, it caters to novice anglers while excelling as a versatile option.
Featuring an aluminium AR-C Spool, the compact 1000 size suits perch fishing and feeder fishing, while the 4000 size is optimal for pursuing trout, salmon, and pike.
Pros
- Aluminium AR-C Spool.
- G-free body design improves reel balance.
Cons
- Drag is not as smooth as higher-end reels.
- Reel Size: 1000 – 4000
- Gear Ratio: 5.0:1 – 5.2:1
- Line Capacity: 0.18-170 – 0.30/180
- Max Drag: 6.6lbs – 18lbs
My Thoughts
When comparing this to other reel models Shimano has developed, the Catana stands out with its enhanced balance, thanks to the G-free body design. This feature significantly improves feel, control, and casting performance.
The improved balance is achieved by relocating the oscillation mechanism from the bottom to the top of the reel. Although it’s not considered a high-end reel, I still really enjoy its feel in hand as well as its ability to subdue hard-fighting fish.
Shimano Baitrunner ST RB – Best For Carp Fishing
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
This reel is well-suited for targeting a variety of coarse species, making it an ideal choice for beginner anglers. Its user-friendly rear bait runner-free spool system simplifies operation. Coupled with features like the aluminium AR-C spool and varispeed line lay, it delivers exceptional performance across the board.
Pros
- Extremely versatile.
- Easy to use free spool Baitrunner mechanism.
- Simple to use for beginner anglers.
Cons
- Some anglers report poor line lay.
- Reel Size: 2500 – 10000
- Gear Ratio: 4.6:1
- Line Capacity: 0.30-270 – 0.35-350
- Max Drag: 13lb
My Thoughts
Having personally owned this reel for the past three years, I’ve been consistently impressed by its performance. I initially purchased it in the 10000 size, and it has proven its strength time and again, effortlessly handling hefty double-figure pike.
I’ve also extensively used it in the carp scene, where it has never failed to reel in larger fish comfortably. It’s reassuring to know that I have a reel capable of handling any size fish without excessively tiring them out.
Shimano Baitrunner DL RB – Best Tension Sensitivity
What Is The Reel Best Suited For?
The reel is particularly well-suited for anglers engaged in extended sessions targeting specimen carp. For optimal balance, pairing the 10000-size reel with a mid-strength test curve carp rod is recommended.
Alternatively, if you prefer a lighter setup, the 6000 size is perfect for specialist coarse fishing. Featuring a rear drag system, the reel facilitates fine-tuning during prolonged battles. However, some anglers may dislike the non-traditional approach, it seems to be a matter of personal preference.
Pros
- Baitrunner free-spool mechanism
- Shimano Shielded Stainless Steel Bearings
- AR-C spool
- Varispeed line lay
- Double handle
Cons
- Slightly more expensive than the ST model.
- Reel Size: 6000 – 10000
- Gear Ratio: 4.6
- Line Capacity: 0.30-270 – 0.35-350
- Max Drag: 13.2lbs
My Thoughts
II like the performance of this reel as well as its dual handle. It’s worth noting that the main differences between it and the ST are the metal spool and the X7 (composite) spool, making it approximately £20 more expensive. I didn’t see this difference as significant enough at the time of purchase, so I opted for the ST RB. However, many anglers would argue otherwise.
FAQs
In this section, we’ll address some frequently asked questions about Shimano’s range of high-quality reels.
What are better Daiwa or Shimano reels?
Shimano reels are often considered superior to Daiwa reels in terms of performance, although they tend to be slightly more expensive. The higher cost of Shimano reels is justified by their superior smoothness and durability compared to Daiwa reels.
While Daiwa does produce some excellent reels known for their versatility, as a general rule, Shimano reels outperform them.
Which country are Shimano reels made in?
Shimano reels are primarily manufactured in Japan, particularly their high-end products like the TWIN POWER FE. Conversely, lower-tier products are commonly produced in factories located in Thailand and Malaysia.
Shimano’s top-tier groupsets utilize lighter yet durable materials, prioritizing performance and longevity. On the other hand, lower-tier groups focus on affordability without compromising essential features.
When considering a Shimano product, it’s crucial to weigh these factors to ensure you invest in the quality that best suits your needs.
What makes Shimano reels stand out as some of the best available?
Shimano’s incorporation of ‘cold-forged’ technology makes their reel strength and durability in their frames unparalleled. Their attention to design, component construction, appearance, and quality control all contribute to the superior quality of their final products.
Who is the Shimano Catana designed for?
The Shimano Catana is specifically designed for anglers who prioritize quality without breaking the bank. It is best suited for anglers who are feeder fishing enthusiasts. Sizes 1000 are best suited for perch and feeder anglers whereas 4000 is perfect for trout, pike, and salmon anglers.
When you purchase a Shimano Catana you should be aware that the 2500, C3000, and 4000 sizes stand out with their high gear retrieve ratio, ranging from 5.8 to 6.2:1, thanks to the incorporation of zinc DC gears.
What is the difference between the Shimano 6000 and 10000 bait runner?
The Shimano 6000 and 10000 bait runners cater to different angling needs and preferences. The 6000 model is tailored for specialist fishing, ideal for smaller venues and lighter setups.
In contrast, the 10000 version is designed for power, enhancing casting distance, and is suitable for tackling larger fish, as it can accommodate stronger lines on the spool.
Additionally, when considering a purchase between the two, it’s essential to note whether it features rear drag (RB) or front drag (FD). While rear drag may be less traditional, it offers more accuracy for fine-tuning the drag during prolonged battles with sizable carp and pike.
The Final Word
Shimano offers a diverse and impressive lineup of fishing reels, tailored to anglers of all techniques and styles.
Whether you’re interested in specimen carp fishing or enjoy jigging for perch, Shimano has you covered with options like the brand-new Twin Power FE and the reliable Shimano Vanford.
We trust that today’s article has provided you with the necessary information to choose the ideal Shimano reel for your fishing needs, while also addressing any queries you may have along the way.
